Looking to upgrade your roof but unsure which metal system is right for your property? You’re not alone. With so many types of metal roofing available today, it’s essential to compare their strengths, styles, and long-term performance. This metal roofing comparison guide will walk you through how to compare metal roofing systems, helping you decide which is best suited for your home or commercial building.
Whether you’re focused on durability, style, energy efficiency, or cost, understanding your metal roofing options will help you make an informed decision with confidence.
Why Metal Roofing Is a Top Choice Today
Before diving into the details, it helps to understand why metal roofing continues to grow in popularity. Homeowners and business owners alike are drawn to metal roofs for several key reasons:
✔ Longevity – Most metal roofs last 40–70 years or more
✔ Durability – Excellent resistance to wind, hail, fire, and pests
✔ Sustainability – Often made from recycled materials and fully recyclable
✔ Energy efficiency – Reflects solar radiation, reducing cooling costs
✔ Low maintenance – Minimal upkeep compared to other roofing materials
Now, let’s compare metal roofing systems based on material type, performance, and ideal use cases.
Types of Metal Roofing Materials
1. Steel Roofing
Steel is the most widely used metal for roofing. It’s available in several variations, each offering different levels of protection and aesthetics.
Pros:
✔ Highly durable and strong
✔ Cost-effective compared to other metals
✔ Can be coated (Galvalume or galvanized) to improve corrosion resistance
Cons:
✘ Prone to rust without proper coating
✘ Heavier than aluminum
Best For:
Commercial buildings, barns, and homes in non-coastal areas.
Popular Styles:
- Corrugated panels
- Standing seam
- R-panel
2. Aluminum Roofing
Aluminum is lightweight, corrosion-resistant, and performs well in coastal climates due to its natural rust resistance.
Pros:
✔ Lightweight and easy to install
✔ Naturally resists rust and corrosion
✔ Highly reflective for solar heat deflection
Cons:
✘ Slightly more expensive than steel
✘ Softer material—can dent more easily
Best For:
Homes near saltwater, light commercial buildings, and energy-conscious buyers.
Popular Styles:
- Standing seam
- Shingle-style aluminum roofing
- Aluminum shake roofing
3. Copper Roofing
Copper is one of the most premium and visually striking options in the metal roofing family. It ages naturally to a beautiful green patina and lasts for more than a century.
Pros:
✔ Lifespan of 70–100+ years
✔ Rust- and corrosion-resistant
✔ Distinct, elegant appearance
Cons:
✘ Very high upfront cost
✘ Requires experienced installation
Best For:
High-end residential homes, historic restorations, churches, and government buildings.
4. Zinc Roofing
Zinc is another top-tier roofing metal known for its self-healing surface and long lifespan. Like copper, it develops a protective patina that resists corrosion.
Pros:
✔ Long lifespan (60–100+ years)
✔ Naturally resists weathering and scratches
✔ Low maintenance over time
Cons:
✘ Higher material and installation cost
✘ Limited availability in some regions
Best For:
Architectural builds, green homes, and custom residential designs.
Learn more about the sustainable advantages of zinc and other metal roofing materials from the National Institute of Building Sciences: NIBS Metal Roofing Performance Guide
5. Tin Roofing (Terne Metal)
Traditional “tin” roofs were made from terne-coated steel or iron. While largely replaced by modern materials, terne metal is still used in restoration projects and some specialty builds.
Pros:
✔ Classic look for historical homes
✔ Good corrosion resistance with modern coatings
Cons:
✘ Not widely available
✘ Requires regular upkeep
Best For:
Historic buildings and restoration projects where maintaining an original appearance is essential.
Comparing Metal Roofing Styles
Choosing the right material is just one part of the equation—you also need to select the roofing style that best suits your building. Let’s break down the most common styles:
Standing Seam Metal Roofing
Overview:
Features concealed fasteners and vertical seams for a sleek, modern look.
Pros:
✔ Excellent weather resistance
✔ Minimal maintenance
✔ Clean, modern aesthetic
Best For:
Commercial roofs, modern homes, energy-efficient buildings
Corrugated Metal Panels
Overview:
Recognizable by their rippled surface, these panels are often used in agricultural and industrial settings.
Pros:
✔ Affordable and widely available
✔ Easy to install
✔ Strong and durable
Best For:
Barns, warehouses, sheds, and budget-conscious commercial projects
Metal Shingles and Shakes
Overview:
Designed to mimic wood, slate, or tile—offering a more traditional look with the benefits of metal.
Pros:
✔ Aesthetic variety
✔ Lighter weight than stone or tile
✔ Suitable for residential properties
Best For:
Homes that want the look of natural materials with enhanced performance
Stone-Coated Steel Roofing
Overview:
Combines the strength of steel with a decorative stone coating for durability and beauty.
Pros:
✔ Impact-resistant
✔ Aesthetic options to match asphalt or tile
✔ Resistant to cracking and fading
Best For:
Storm-prone areas, high-end homes, multi-family buildings
Cost Comparison: What to Expect
Here’s a basic cost comparison for types of metal roofing, not including labor:
| Metal Type | Material Cost (Per Sq. Ft.) |
| Steel (Galvanized) | $4.00 – $6.50 |
| Aluminum | $6.50 – $10.00 |
| Copper | $14.00 – $25.00 |
| Zinc | $12.00 – $18.00 |
Labor can vary based on region and complexity, but always include it when requesting bids.
Metal Roofing Lifespan and Maintenance
Regardless of which type you choose, metal roofing is known for exceptional durability and lifespan. On average:
- Steel: 40–60 years
- Aluminum: 50–70 years
- Copper and Zinc: 70–100+ years
Minimal maintenance involves occasional inspections, clearing debris, and checking for fastener tightness or coating wear. These practices help extend life and preserve your warranty.
Choosing the Best Metal Roof Types for Your Needs
Now that you’ve reviewed the metal roofing comparison guide, it’s time to ask the right questions:
✔ What is your budget?
✔ What are the climate conditions in your area?
✔ Are aesthetics a top priority?
✔ Do you need a roof for a home, business, or specialty project?
Whether you want the best metal roof types for performance or appearance, matching the right material and style to your goals is key.
Ready to Explore Metal Roofing Options? Let’s Talk
At Home Source Roofing, we help homeowners and business owners make smart roofing decisions. From explaining how to compare metal roofing systems to expert installation of the best metal roof types, our team is here to guide you every step of the way.
Our experts will evaluate your needs, provide a tailored recommendation, and ensure your investment stands the test of time. Don’t wait—get a free inspection now and explore the best metal roofing options for your property!
